Geographys

American Samoa

The one place where being born on US soil makes you a US national but not a US citizen. People born there can live and work anywhere in the United States, but cannot vote there, and in 2022 the Supreme Court left that rule in place.

Written from cited sourcesLast checked 26 October 2026Suggest a correction

TUTUILASOUTH PACIFIC OCEANPago Pago
Tutuila, the main island, with Pago Pago. The Manu’a group lies about 100 km further east, off this map.

See it on the globe:American Samoa →United States →

The eastern islands

American Samoa is the part of the Samoan islands east of 171° W, in the South Pacific about 3,500 km southwest of Hawaii. The independent country of Samoa, about 130 km to the west, holds the islands west of that line.[2]

Its main island, Tutuila, covers 135 km² and is nearly cut in two by Pago Pago Harbor. The capital, Pago Pago, is there. The Manu’a group lies about 100 km to the east, and Swains Island, a separate coral atoll about 450 km northwest of Tutuila, was added in 1925.[2] More than nine in ten people are Samoan. The extended family, headed by a chief called a matai, is the basic unit of society, and councils of matai run village affairs.[2][1]

How it became American

In 1878 the United States signed a treaty for a naval station in Pago Pago Harbor. An 1899 agreement between the colonial powers split Samoa: Germany took the western islands and the United States the eastern ones.[5]

On 17 April 1900 the chiefs of Tutuila and Aunu’u signed an instrument ceding their islands to the United States, and on 14 July 1904 the chiefs of Manu’a did the same.[3] Congress did not formally accept the deeds of cession until 20 February 1929. The US Navy ran the islands from 1900 to 1951, when the Department of the Interior took over.[5]

Congress never passed an act setting up a government for the territory. Instead the Interior Department let American Samoa write its own constitution in 1967. Voters approved electing their own governor in 1976, and the first elected governor, Peter Coleman, took office in 1977. The legislature, the Fono, has an elected House of Representatives and a Senate still chosen by councils of chiefs.[1][5]

Nationals, not citizens

People born in Puerto Rico, Guam, the US Virgin Islands and the Northern Mariana Islands are US citizens, because Congress passed laws making them so. Congress has passed no such law for American Samoa.[2] Federal law instead lists it as an “outlying possession” and says people born there are “nationals, but not citizens, of the United States at birth”.[3]

As nationals they can enter, live and work in the United States, but they cannot vote there.[2][1] The plaintiffs in a later court case listed other limits: living in Utah, they could not sit on a jury or become police officers, and their US passports carried a note saying they were not citizens.[3]

“nationals, but not citizens, of the United States at birth”[3]

8 U.S.C. § 1408(1), on people born in an outlying possession of the United States

The court case

In 2018 three people born in American Samoa and living in Utah, led by John Fitisemanu, sued. They argued that the Fourteenth Amendment makes everyone born “in the United States” a citizen, and that a territory counts. The American Samoa government and its delegate in Congress, Aumua Amata, joined the case on the other side. A federal district court in Utah agreed with the plaintiffs.[3]

In June 2021 a divided panel of the Tenth Circuit Court of Appeals reversed that ruling. It relied on the Insular Cases, a series of early-1900s Supreme Court decisions about territories, and pointed to the role of the Samoan way of life, the fa’a Samoa, and the wishes of the territory’s elected leaders.[6][3] The court refused to rehear the case in December 2021, over the dissent of two judges.[7] On 17 October 2022 the Supreme Court declined to take it.[4]

Fitisemanu called the outcome “a punch in the gut”. Amata welcomed it, saying it helped protect family land and matai heritage, and said any change should come from Congress.[6]

Timeline

  1. 1878

    Naval station

    The United States signs a treaty for a station in Pago Pago Harbor.[5]

  2. 1899

    Samoa split

    Germany takes the western islands and the United States the eastern ones.[5]

  3. 190017 April 1900

    Tutuila ceded

    The chiefs of Tutuila and Aunu’u cede their islands to the United States.[3]

  4. 190414 July 1904

    Manu’a ceded

    The chiefs of the Manu’a islands follow.[3]

  5. 1925

    Swains Island

    The atoll is made part of American Samoa.[2]

  6. 192920 February 1929

    Congress accepts

    Congress formally accepts the deeds of cession.[5]

  7. 1951

    Navy leaves

    The Department of the Interior takes over from the US Navy.[5]

  8. 1967

    Constitution

    American Samoa adopts its own constitution.[1]

  9. 1977

    Elected governor

    Peter Coleman becomes the first elected governor.[5]

  10. 2021

    Appeals ruling

    The Tenth Circuit rules against birthright citizenship for American Samoa.[6]

  11. 202217 October 2022

    Supreme Court declines

    The justices refuse to hear Fitisemanu v. United States.[4]

More map oddities

Sources

  1. [1]
    American Samoa: Government and society · Encyclopaedia Britannica
  2. [2]
    American Samoa · Encyclopaedia Britannica
  3. [3]
    Fitisemanu v. United States, petition for a writ of certiorari, No. 21-1394 · Supreme Court of the United States (filed by the plaintiffs) · 27 April 2022

    One side’s brief; used for the documents it quotes and the case’s history.

  4. [4]
    Docket No. 21-1394, Fitisemanu v. United States · Supreme Court of the United States
  5. [5]
    American Samoa: History · Encyclopaedia Britannica
  6. [6]
    Supreme Court skips over American Samoa’s citizenship case · Pacific Island Times · 17 October 2022
  7. [7]
    Fitisemanu v. United States, Nos. 20-4017 and 20-4019, order denying rehearing en banc · United States Court of Appeals for the Tenth Circuit · 27 December 2021

Map geometry from Natural Earth via world-atlas. See credits.

Know a better source? Send a link for any fact on this page.
Primary sources (treaties, court rulings, official records) help most.